reviews
Wellputt vs Perfect Practice: I Tested Both, $89-189
Two Reddit threads, one from 2021 and one from 2023, ask the exact same question: Wellputt or Perfect Practice? Neither thread has a real answer, just a scattering of opinions and one paragraph buried inside a third-party review nobody reads past the headline. Meanwhile both mats keep selling, and buyers keep guessing based on whichever one showed up in their Instagram feed that week.
I have used both mats at home for months. They are not solving the same problem, and once you see that, the decision gets a lot easier.
The Contenders
- Wellputt 10ft Classic ($148.99): app-guided drills, dual-direction turf, Cameron McCormick-designed training system
- Wellputt 13ft Green ($189): same features as the Classic, full 13-foot length
- Perfect Practice Putting Mat ($110-$150): auto ball return, two hole sizes, DJ-endorsed
What Each One Is Actually Built to Do
Wellputt is a data mat. It has a dual-direction turf, one side rolls at roughly 10 on the stimp for accuracy work, the other at 11.5 for distance control, and both sides carry a “Good Zone / Bad Zone” marking behind the hole that teaches proper pace. Miss short and you land in the Bad Zone. Roll 12 to 24 inches past the cup and you land in the Good Zone, which is exactly the lag-putting window a coach would want you in. Pair the mat with the free Wellputt app, more than 50 drills designed by coach Cameron McCormick, and you get a structured practice system, not just a strip of turf.
Perfect Practice solves a different problem entirely: repetition without the tedium of walking to retrieve your ball. It uses a magnetic ball-return track that sends a made putt straight back to you, and it includes two hole sizes so you can train on a slightly larger target before tightening up to regulation. There is no app, no drills, and no coaching philosophy behind it. It is a machine for getting more reps in less time.
If you want a mat that teaches you something new, buy Wellputt. If you want a mat that removes friction so you actually practice more often, buy Perfect Practice.
Price Reality Check
Wellputt’s pricing is where most buyers get confused, because older reviews conflate the models. The current lineup is the 10ft Start 2.0 at $89, the 10ft Classic at $148.99, and the 13ft models at $189. That $89 entry point is a legitimate budget option, but it skips the training book and higher-grade turf that come with the Classic.
Perfect Practice runs $110 for the Compact 8-footer and $150 for the Standard 9.5-footer. There is no $60 model anymore, despite what some older buying guides still say. At the low end, Perfect Practice actually costs slightly more than Wellputt’s cheapest option, which surprises most people going in.
The App Question
Wellputt’s $60 premium over Perfect Practice’s entry price only makes sense if you will actually open the app. It runs on iOS and Android, though the Android version pulls more crash complaints in user reviews than iOS does. If your idea of practice is turning on a podcast and rolling putts for 15 minutes, you will never use the 50 drills you paid for, and you are better off with the cheaper mat.
Perfect Practice’s biggest reported weakness is mechanical, not digital. Multiple Amazon reviewers report the magnetic ball-return track wearing out after 6 to 12 months of heavy use. It is not universal, but it is common enough that if you are the type who putts every single day, budget for eventual wear.
Who Should Buy Wellputt
Buy Wellputt if you are a serious, data-driven putter who wants structured practice and will actually follow the app’s drills. The dual-direction turf and Good Zone markings genuinely teach pace control, which is the single biggest lever for lowering your putts per round. Golfers who already track stats, use a launch monitor, or work with an instructor are the exact audience this mat rewards.
Who Should Buy Perfect Practice
Buy Perfect Practice if you want the simplest path to more reps. The auto return means you spend your practice time putting instead of bending over to collect balls, which matters if you have limited time or a bad back. It is also the more honest budget pick for most casual golfers, since you are not paying for an app you will likely ignore after the first week.
The Verdict
If you will use the app, Wellputt is worth the extra $40 to $100 over Perfect Practice. The Good Zone training alone will lower your three-putts faster than any mat without it. If you know yourself well enough to admit you will never open a training app, buy the Perfect Practice Compact at $110 and just put in more reps. Both mats will make you a better putter. The one that actually gets used every day will make you a better putter faster, and that is the honest deciding factor here, not the feature list.
I keep my Wellputt out because I use the app. If you are not going to, save the money and get the Perfect Practice instead. That is less than two rounds of golf at a mid-tier public course, and it is the more honest starting point for most readers.
Where to Buy
- Wellputt 10ft Classic $148.99 at Amazon
- Wellputt 13ft Green $189 at Amazon
- Perfect Practice Putting Mat $110-$150 at Amazon
Prices verified July 2026. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.